“Why are Medicare Advantage plans bad?” And other questions you’re afraid to ask out loud

Medicare Open Enrollment Post It

You’ve probably landed on this page because you’ve been looking for information about why Medicare Advantage (Medicare Part C) plans are bad. Medicare open enrollment is fast-approaching, so good on you for doing your thorough research! Medicare can be a tricky system to understand. That’s why we’re starting a series of articles all about Medicare to address America’s most frequently asked questions. We’re starting with why Medicare Advantage plans are bad (spoiler alert: They’re not!) and answering all of the necessary questions to help you make informed decisions about your Medicare plan. 

So, Why are Medicare Advantage Plans bad?  

The perception of Medicare Advantage plans being “bad” is subjective and can vary based on individual preferences, healthcare needs, and personal experiences. Truth be told, if you feel your Medicare Advantage plan is “bad” it might just not be right for you. While Medicare Advantage plans offer additional benefits and coverage options beyond Original Medicare, some people may have concerns or negative experiences with these plans for the reasons listed below. It should be noted that these processes are quite common across all different types of insurance, they are not exclusive to Medicare Advantage plans.  

  • Limited Provider Networks: Medicare Advantage plans often operate as managed care plans, such as HMOs or PPOs, which means you may be required to use a specific network of healthcare providers and facilities. This limitation could be problematic for individuals who prefer to see certain doctors or specialists who are not part of the plan’s network. 
  • Prior Authorization Requirements: Some Medicare Advantage plans may have more stringent requirements for obtaining prior authorization before receiving certain medical services or treatments. This could potentially delay access to care, which may be a concern for people with urgent medical needs. 
  • Regional Coverage: The availability and scope of Medicare Advantage plans can vary by region. In some areas, there may be limited plan options, which could result in less competition and potentially higher costs for beneficiaries. 
  • Cost-Sharing: While Medicare Advantage plans often offer additional benefits, they may also have higher co-payments, coinsurance, and deductibles for certain services compared to Original Medicare. For individuals who frequently use healthcare services, these out-of-pocket costs could add up. 
  • Plan Changes: Medicare Advantage plans can make changes to their benefits, formularies, and provider networks from year to year. This can be a source of frustration for beneficiaries who may need to switch plans if their current one no longer meets their needs. 
  • Complexity: Medicare Advantage plans can be complex, and beneficiaries may find it challenging to navigate the various rules, coverage options, and administrative aspects of these plans. 

Despite these concerns, it’s essential to remember that Medicare Advantage plans also have several advantages- after all, it’s in the name. They can provide additional benefits such as prescription drug coverage, dental, vision, and hearing services, and many people find them cost-effective and suitable for their healthcare needs. The suitability of a Medicare Advantage plan depends on individual circumstances, preferences, and the specific plan’s features. If you’re considering enrolling in a Medicare Advantage plan, it’s crucial to carefully review the plan’s details and compare it to your healthcare requirements before making a decision. 

In order to understand why Medicare Advantage plans are bad, or why they are beneficial, we must first understand the structure of the plan itself. 

What are the worst Medicare Advantage plans? 

There really are no “worst Medicare Advantage plans,” just plans that may not be the right fit for you and your healthcare needs. Medicare Advantage plans are offered by private insurance companies and can differ significantly in terms of coverage, costs, provider networks, and additional benefits. This is really no different from when you would shop insurance plans and/or providers for your traditional insurance before. What might be considered the “worst” plan for one person could be the best option for someone else, depending on their specific circumstances.  

Instead of focusing on the worst Medicare Advantage plans, it’s more helpful to consider factors that may lead to a Medicare Advantage plan not being a good fit for a particular individual: 

  • Limited Provider Network: Plans with restrictive provider networks may not cover the preferred healthcare providers or specialists of certain beneficiaries. Yes, it’s true. The shift to Medicare coverage may also mean you’ll have to find a new doctor. For most this is an unavoidable reality, but not an unfamiliar one.  
  • High Out-of-Pocket Costs: Plans with high co-payments, coinsurance, or deductibles for essential services or medications could lead to higher healthcare expenses. This is best managed by working with a dedicated Medicare insurance agent who can take into account your needs and best match you with the right Medicare plans. 
  • Inadequate Coverage for Specific Needs: Some plans may not cover certain medical services, medications, or treatments that are vital for a particular individual’s health conditions. 
  • Frequent Plan Changes: Plans that make significant changes to their benefits, formularies, or provider networks each year may cause inconvenience for beneficiaries who need stability in their healthcare coverage. 
  • Complex Prior Authorization Requirements: Plans with overly stringent prior authorization requirements may delay access to necessary medical treatments or services. 
  • Poor Customer Service or Plan Ratings: Plans with low satisfaction ratings or complaints about customer service may not provide a positive experience for beneficiaries. 

To avoid ending up with a plan that doesn’t meet your needs, it’s essential to thoroughly research and compare the Medicare Advantage plans available in your area. Take into consideration factors such as coverage, costs, provider networks, and any additional benefits that are essential for your healthcare requirements. 

Additionally, consider seeking assistance from licensed insurance agents, Medicare counselors, or trusted healthcare advisors who can provide personalized guidance based on your unique situation and help you choose a Medicare Advantage plan that aligns with your needs and preferences. 


Why do doctors not like Medicare Advantage plans?  

While it’s not accurate to say that all doctors dislike Medicare Advantage plans, some physicians and healthcare providers may have concerns or reservations about certain aspects of these plans. It’s important to note that individual experiences and perspectives can vary, and not all doctors hold negative views of Medicare Advantage. Some reasons why some doctors may have concerns about Medicare Advantage plans include: 

  • Limited Provider Networks: Medicare Advantage plans often operate as managed care plans with specific provider networks. Doctors may be hesitant to join these networks due to potential reimbursement rates or administrative burdens. This can lead to some beneficiaries finding that their preferred doctors or specialists are not part of the plan’s network. 
  • Reimbursement Rates: Medicare Advantage plans negotiate reimbursement rates with healthcare providers, which may be lower than the rates for traditional Medicare. Some doctors may be concerned that lower reimbursement rates could affect their ability to cover their practice costs adequately. 
  • Prior Authorization Requirements: Some Medicare Advantage plans have more stringent prior authorization requirements for certain medical services or treatments. Doctors may find these requirements burdensome and time-consuming, potentially delaying access to necessary care for patients. 
  • Plan Changes: Medicare Advantage plans can change their benefits, formularies, and provider networks annually. Doctors may find it challenging to keep up with these changes and adapt their practices accordingly. 
  • Administrative Burden: Doctors may feel that dealing with multiple Medicare Advantage plans, each with its own administrative processes and requirements, adds complexity to their practices. 
  • Inconsistent Payment Policies: Doctors may experience variability in payment policies and delays in receiving payments from different Medicare Advantage plans. 
  • Patient Churning: Some doctors may be concerned about “patient churning,” where patients frequently switch between Medicare Advantage plans due to annual enrollment periods or plan changes. This can lead to disruptions in patient care and continuity. 

It’s essential to recognize that many doctors do participate in Medicare Advantage plans and provide high-quality care to their patients under these plans. Additionally, some doctors may see advantages in Medicare Advantage plans, such as coordinated care models and financial incentives for managing chronic conditions effectively. 

Overall, the relationship between doctors and Medicare Advantage plans can be complex, and any concerns may be specific to certain plans or individual experiences. Beneficiaries should still have access to a broad network of healthcare providers, but it’s always a good idea to check with individual doctors to confirm their participation in the specific Medicare Advantage plan you are considering. Open communication between doctors and patients can help ensure a positive healthcare experience under Medicare Advantage plans. 


Thusfar, we’ve debunked all of the negative perceptions of Medicare Advantage plans (Medicare Part C) and we hope you’ve come away with a fresh perspective. If you are still looking for information about why Medicare Advantage plans are bad, which are the worst, and why doctors don’t like Part C, the best course of action for you is to find a Medicare-dedicated insurance representative in your area. These are folks who eat, sleep, and breathe Medicare. They will be your best source of knowledge and your first line of defense for receiving the best Medicare structure for you and your specific needs. Remember; There are no bad Medicare Advantage plans, only Medicare Advantage plans that may not be right for you.  

Contact Form

  • Contact

    This is to contact our corporate office. If you’re interested in contacting an individual QuickRx pharmacy, please visit our Locations Pages or you can Give Us a Call at the Headquarters (212) 249-8202. If you want immediate specialty pharmacy services please call: (347)-691-3494